Google Pixel 9 Pro XL: 3-Month Review – Pros & Cons

Three months with the Pixel 9 Pro XL reveals a phone with real strengths and some stubborn trade-offs. It’s a capable flagship with a gorgeous display, improved battery life, and a camera system that leans heavily on AI — but it also costs a lot and doesn’t beat every competitor in raw specs.

Display size: 6.8 inches LTPO OLED ·
Processor: Google Tensor G4 ·
Battery capacity: 5060 mAh ·
Rear camera: 50 MP + 48 MP + 48 MP ·
Release date: August 2024 ·
Starting price (USD): $1,099

Twelve key specs, one pattern: the Pixel 9 Pro XL is a fully loaded flagship with few hardware compromises.

Is the Pixel 9 Pro XL any good?

What do reviewers say after three months?

• According to Thurrott (tech review site), the phone’s pros include a stunning premium design, gorgeous display, terrific camera and photography features, helpful Pixel features, future-proof components, fast and accurate face and fingerprint recognition, and improved battery life and quick charging.
• The same review notes the display supports HDR10/10+ but not Dolby Vision, with a peak brightness of 3000 nits and 2000 nits for HDR content (Thurrott).
• ViserMark (specs aggregator) confirms the 6.80-inch LTPO OLED display with 120Hz adaptive refresh rate and IP68 water/dust resistance.

The implication: after three months, reviewers consistently praise the hardware and camera performance, but note the premium price tag remains a barrier for many buyers.

What makes it stand out from last year’s model?

• The Tensor G4 chip delivers noticeable performance improvements over the G3, especially in AI processing and image tasks (Thurrott).
• Camera quality remains strong across lighting conditions, with the 48 MP telephoto providing 5x optical zoom (ViserMark).
• Build quality features Gorilla Glass Victus 2 front and back with a polished aluminum frame (ViserMark).

What are the disadvantages of the Pixel 9 Pro XL?

Are there any common hardware issues?

• Thurrott lists cons as being expensive, somewhat too similar to the iPhone, and having too much software to keep track of.
• Some users have reported heating issues during extended gaming or video recording, though not widely documented (Twenty First Tech (tech blog)).
• No charger included in the box – a common but notable omission at this price point.

The pattern: hardware concerns are minor and isolate to specific use cases, but the lack of an included charger frustrates some buyers at the $1,099 starting price.

How does the battery hold up over time?

• Thurrott characterizes the battery as an all-day battery in normal use, but it still underperforms the iPhone 15 Pro Max, iPhone 16 Pro Max, and Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (Thurrott).
• Wired charging is 45W, which is slower than many competitors’ 65W+ options (ViserMark).

Is there a difference between Google Pixel 9 Pro and 9 Pro XL?

Which one should you buy?

• The 9 Pro XL has a 6.8-inch display versus 6.3 inches on the Pro; battery capacity is larger (5060 mAh vs 4700 mAh) (ViserMark).
• Both have identical processors (Tensor G4), same camera hardware (50+48+48 MP rear, 42 MP front), and same RAM (16 GB) (Google Store (official product page)).
• Weight: 221g (XL) vs 199g (Pro) – the XL is noticeably heavier (ViserMark).
• Price difference is typically $100 at the same storage tier (Google Store).

The catch: the only real differences are screen size, battery, weight, and price — core performance and camera experience are identical.

Do both have the same camera system?

Yes, the camera hardware is identical – both models share the same 50 MP main, 48 MP ultrawide, 48 MP telephoto, and 42 MP front camera (ViserMark). The only differences are physical size, weight, battery capacity, and price.

How does the Pixel 9 Pro XL compare to the Samsung S24 Ultra?

Four key areas reveal one clear advantage for each phone — your choice depends on what matters more.

Which has a better camera?

• The Pixel 9 Pro XL’s AI-powered features (Magic Editor, Photo Unblur) give it an edge in computational photography (Google Store).
• The S24 Ultra offers more versatility with a 10x optical zoom lens and a 200 MP sensor for high-resolution cropping (Samsung (official site)).

The pattern: Pixel wins on AI-driven corrections and night shots; Samsung wins on raw zoom reach and resolution flexibility.

Which offers better value for money?

• The Pixel 9 Pro XL starts at $1,099, while the S24 Ultra starts at $1,299 (often discounted to ~$1,099) (Google Store).
• Both receive 7 years of software updates, but Pixel has a cleaner Android experience with exclusive AI features.
• For users who prioritize zoom and S Pen, the S24 Ultra wins; for AI-driven photography and pure Android, the Pixel does.

Is the Pixel 9 Pro XL worth buying?

Who should buy this phone?

• Photography enthusiasts who rely on AI enhancements (Google Store).
• Users who want long-term software support without bloatware.
• Anyone upgrading from a Pixel 6 or 7 who wants the best Pixel experience.

The implication: this phone is best suited for Google ecosystem loyalists and mobile photography enthusiasts who value computational features over raw hardware specifications.

Are there better alternatives at this price?

• The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers more hardware features (S Pen, 10x zoom, better battery) for a similar price after discounts.
• iPhone 16 Pro Max has superior battery life and video recording (Thurrott).
• OnePlus 12 provides faster charging and similar performance for less money.

Pixel 9 Pro XL timeline

• August 2024 – Google announces Pixel 9 Pro and Pixel 9 Pro XL at Made by Google event (Google Store (official product page))
• September 2024 – First units ship; initial reviews published (Thurrott (tech review site))
• October 2024 – First software update (Android 14 QPR1 beta) rolled out
• November 2024 – Early adopter feedback emerges; three-month usage reports begin (Twenty First Tech (tech blog))
• January 2025 – Expected Android 15 update for Pixel devices

What we know for sure vs what’s still uncertain

Confirmed facts

• Pixel 9 Pro XL released August 2024 with Tensor G4 chip (Thurrott (tech review site))
• Display is 6.8-inch LTPO OLED with 120Hz (ViserMark (specs aggregator))
• Battery capacity 5060 mAh (ViserMark)
• Camera specifications as listed on Google Store
• 7 years of software updates promised (Google Store (official product page))

What’s still uncertain

• Long-term battery degradation after 2+ years
• Actual resale value retention
• Effectiveness of AI features in non-English languages
• Consistency of camera performance across software updates

“The Pixel 9 Pro XL has a stunning premium design, gorgeous display, and a terrific camera system – but it’s expensive and feels too similar to the iPhone.”

– Thurrott (tech review site), summarizing three months of use (Thurrott)

“The Tensor G4 brings meaningful AI upgrades, especially in photography and voice recognition, making the Pixel 9 Pro XL feel smarter than its competitors.”

– Google Store (official product page) product description (Google Store)

“After three months, the battery holds up well for normal use, but heavy users will still need a top-up by evening.”

– Tech Advisor (tech publication), three-month usage report (Tech Advisor)

For a US buyer in early 2025, the choice is clear: if you value camera AI and long-term updates over raw zoom and S Pen, the Pixel 9 Pro XL is a solid buy; for everyone else, the Galaxy S24 Ultra offers more hardware features for a similar price. The Pixel’s seven-year software commitment means it will serve photography enthusiasts well into 2031.

For a different perspective, our readers may also appreciate this Japanese Google Pixel 9 Pro XL review after three months of daily use.

Frequently asked questions